Words of Wisdom:

"i wish i could eat your cancer when you turn black.-kurt cobain" - Acteleleaflndo

Japanese and American Workers: Two Casts of Mind

  • Date Submitted: 04/22/2010 06:57 PM
  • Flesch-Kincaid Score: 38.4 
  • Words: 2122
  • Essay Grade: no grades
  • Report this Essay
Japanese and American Workers:   Two Casts of Mind
by William Ouchi

erhaps the most difficult aspect of the Japanese for Westerners to comprehend is the strong orientation to collective values, particularly a collective sense of responsibility. Let me illustrate with an anecdote about a visit to a new factory in Japan owned and operated by an American electronics company. The American company, a particularly creative firm, frequently attracts attention within the business community for its novel approaches to planning, organizational design, and management systems. As a consequence of this corporate style, the parent company determined to make a thorough study of Japanese workers and to design a plant that would combine the best of East and West. In their study they discovered that Japanese firms almost never make use of individual work incentives, such as piecework or even individual performance appraisal [evaluation] tied to salary increases. They concluded that rewarding individual achievement and individual ability is always a good thing.
  In the final assembly area of their new plant long lines of young Japanese women wired together electronic products on a piece-rate system: The more you wired, the more you got paid. About two months after opening, the head foreladies approached the plant manager. "Honorable plant manager," they said humbly as they bowed, "we are embarrassed to be so forward, but we must speak to you because all of the girls have threatened to quit work this Friday." (To have this happen, of course, would be a great disaster for all concerned.) "Why," they wanted to know, "can't our plant have the same compensation system as other Japanese companies? When you hire a new girl, her starting wage should be fixed by her age. An eighteen-year-old should be paid more than a sixteen-year-old. Every year on her birthday, she should receive an automatic increase in pay. The idea that any one of us can be more productive than another must be...


Express your owns thoughts and ideas on this essay by writing a grade and/or critique.

  1. No comments